KARACHI:
Kamran Khan said on his Geo TV programme ‘Aaj Kamran Khan Kay Sath’ that
a new political controversy has emerged when it was attributed to Gen
(retd) Pervez Musharraf or his new lawyer, Dr Farogh Nasim, that either
Gen (retd) Pervez Musharraf or he wants the army to either dissociate
itself from Gen (retd) Pervez Musharraf and announce that the decision
of November 3 was solely Gen (retd) Pervez Musharraf’s or the army
should as an institution accept responsibility for the November 3
emergency.
Kamran Khan said that it has become clear now
that the neither Musharraf nor his lawyer stated so. However, in order
to know the exact situation and to know what Gen (retd) Pervez
Musharraf’s stand is, we are going to talk to Musharraf’s lawyer
Barrister Farogh Nasim.
Kamran Khan: Thank you very much
for being on the programme. Please let us know whether the statement
that the Army should take responsibility for the November 3 act or that
Musharraf should take sole responsibility, is issued by Musharraf or has
it been attributed to you?
Farogh Nasim: I think the
context has been misunderstood because the media is a bit oversensitive.
Maybe some anchors are getting it wrong. However, there is absolutely
nothing like that. I was simply shocked to see a mention in yesterday’s
judgment that when the court asked Musharraf’s lawyers whether it was
Musharraf’s individual act or whether it was on other people’s advice,
they said that it was an individual act and it was not based on other
people’s advice. It was natural for me to be shocked because the
instructions that my client has given me is that “I have acted upon the
advice...I took the action on the advice of my prime minister or that of
the cabinet...and other people were consulted”. So when I asked Pervez
Musharraf, he said it was incorrect so I asked him to kindly ask his
lawyers for a clarification, and then we have to take the appropriate
steps. It’s just nothing. In fact, I am saying that our Army has to play
its constitutional and legal role and adopt whatever legal and
constitutional methodologies there are. Moreover, there is Article 12-2
of the Constitution which says that Article 6 is to be enforced from
March 23, 1956. So enforce the Article from that day. That’s all.
Kamran
Khan: What does Musharraf say? He took the decision on his own, or in
his capacity as the president or as Army chief. He said in his speech
that he enforced emergency in his capacity as the army chief.
Farogh
Nasim: He has given me very clear instructions. I took his instructions
before I took the case. I asked him if that was his “individual act or
whether it was based on other people’s advice and consultation” and he
said it with clarity it was the prime minister’s and the cabinet’s
advice and he acted on that advice.
Kamran Khan: It means
then that Musharraf has told you that the prime minister and the cabinet
were responsible and they gave him the advice. The Army has nothing to
do with it, isn’t it?
Farogh Nasim: He told me quite
clearly: “I was the president of Pakistan on November 3, 2007, and as
president, the prime minister and the cabinet gave me the advice, and in
the light of the advice from the prime minister and the cabinet, I had
no other option under the Constitution other than implementing the
advice because the Constitution says that ‘the president has to act upon
the advice of the PM’.” So the matter ends here. There is nothing else
in the matter. The only complication is that yesterday’s judgment of the
Supreme Court for which Musharraf has to take appropriate steps.
At
the conclusion, Kamran Khan said Nasim has been clearly saying that
Musharraf’s lawyers have made a blunder by saying that it was Gen (R)
Musharraf’s act alone. He said differences among Musharraf’s lawyers in
this connection are widening. Nevertheless, it is now clear that Pervez
Musharraf has never said that the Army should say it was with him in the
act of November 3 or whether it was solely his own decision.