of the
Bush administration's record when it comes to waterboarding and other
"enhanced interrogation techniques." The panel voted 11-3 to order the
declassification of almost 500 pages of the 6,300-page review, which
concludes the harsh methods employed at CIA-run prisons overseas were
excessively cruel and ineffective in producing valuable intelligence.
Even
some Republicans who agree with the spy agency that the findings are
inaccurate voted in favor of declassification, saying it was important
for the country to move on.
"The purpose of this review
was to uncover the facts behind the secret program and the results, I
think, were shocking," Sen. Dianne Feinstein, D-Calif., the committee
chairwoman, said. "The report exposes brutality that stands in sharp
contrast to our values as a nation. It chronicles a stain on our history
that must never be allowed to happen again. This is not what Americans
do."
The intelligence committee and the CIA are embroiled
in a bitter dispute related to the three-year study. Senators accuse the
agency of spying on their investigation and deleting files. The CIA
says Senate staffers illegally accessed information. The Justice
Department is reviewing competing criminal referrals.
As a
result of Thursday's vote, the CIA will start scanning the report's
contents for any passages that could compromise national security. That
has led to fears in the committee that a recalcitrant CIA might sanitize
key elements of their investigation, and demands for President Barack
Obama to ensure large parts of the report aren't blacked out.
Obama, said Sen. Mark Udall, D-Colo., should "hold onto the redaction pen himself."
White
House press secretary Jay Carney on Thursday restated Obama's support
for declassifying the document and said intelligence officials would be
instructed to conduct the work quickly. CIA spokesman Dean Boyd said his
agency would "carry out the review expeditiously," but suggested the
process may be difficult.
"We owe it to the men and women
directed to carry out this program to try and ensure that any historical
account of it is accurate," Boyd said.
The report was
produced exclusively by Democratic staffers. It concludes among other
things that waterboarding and other harsh techniques provided no key
evidence in the hunt for Osama bin Laden, according to congressional
aides and outside experts familiar with the document.
Feinstein
and other senators also have cited a series of misleading claims by the
CIA over the years about the effectiveness of the program, including in
statements the agency made to President George W. Bush and Congress.
Sen.
Saxby Chambliss of Georgia, the intelligence committee's top
Republican, joined the vote in favor of declassification despite
criticizing the report as a "waste of time." He said the U.S. public
should be able to see the report alongside reservations among the GOP
members of the committee.
"This is a chapter in our past
that should have already been closed," Chambliss told reporters. He said
Republicans would dispute some of the conclusions in their own report
and insisted the CIA interrogations "led not only to the takedown of bin
Laden, but to the interruption and disruption of other terrorist plots
over a period of years."
Members of the intelligence
community have criticized the investigation for failing to include
interviews from top spy agency officials who authorized or supervised
the brutal interrogations. They questioned how the review could be fair
or complete.
"Neither I or anyone else at the agency who
had knowledge was interviewed," said Jose Rodriguez, the CIA's chief
clandestine officer in the mid-2000s, who had operational oversight over
the detention and interrogation program. "They don't want to hear
anyone else's narrative," he said of the Senate investigation. "It's an
attempt to rewrite history."
Rodriguez himself is a key
figure in the Senate report, not least for his order in 2005 to destroy
92 videotapes showing waterboarding of terror suspects and other harsh
techniques.
Senate investigators were unable to talk to
relevant CIA officials because of legal constraints posed by a separate
investigation ordered by Attorney General Eric Holder. At Holder's
direction, John Durham, an independent prosecutor, conducted several
criminal probes related to interrogation methods and evidence
destruction before dropping them altogether in 2012 - shortly before the
Senate panel wrapped up its work.
Congressional aides
said the CIA's own field reports, internal correspondence, cables and
other documents described day-to-day handling of interrogations and the
decision-making and actions of Rodriguez and others.
Republican Sens. Marco Rubio of Florida, Dan Coats of Indiana and Jim Risch of Idaho voted against releasing the report.
"Too
much time, energy and too many resources have been spent investigating a
CIA program that ended more than six years ago," Coats said.
Bad
blood between Senate aides and the CIA ruptured into the open last
month when Feinstein took to the Senate floor to accuse the agency of
improperly monitoring the computer use of Senate staffers and deleting
files, undermining the Constitution's separation of powers.
Thus far, both senators and the agency have tried to keep the declassification issue separate from their ongoing dispute.
Feinstein expressed hope that most of the summary and findings would escape CIA censors and reach the public within 30 days.
Sen.
Jay Rockefeller, D-W.Va., said the report's public release is "the only
way we can get this relationship with our intelligence agencies right
again."