ISLAMABAD: A murderous attack on Hamid Mir has been followed by unabated assaults on his employer, Geo TV.
‘Patriotic’
pundits flock to the talk show studios of the TV stations channelled
around Aabpara to condemn the coverage that flashed on the screen the
picture of the DG ISI, as has been accused by the victim journalist’s
family.
Pointing fingers at the ISI chief has been treated
as an attack on the ISI that, they say, resulted in the agency’s
defamation at a global level. A number of anchorpersons playing up the
issue are more interested in raising questions than getting answers.
In
many cases, their ignorance was on blatant display. In the lines below,
I will attempt to address these questions.Question 1: Why were the
allegations hurled at the ISI chief with indecent haste as Geo TV could
have waited for Hamid Mir to regain consciousness and make his
statement?
Answer: Allegations levelled by Amir Mir were
based on a recorded statement that Hamid Mir handed to his family and
friends for its release in case of any attempt on his life. The
allegations might have surprised many viewers but the fact remains that
the victim had shared his concerns with many of his friends and
colleagues. Needless to mention that neither the family traumatised by
this tragic incident was ready to wait nor were his colleagues. They had
planned to lodge a protest and approach other channels in case Geo TV
refused to air the tape. It took a couple of hours to decide before
airing the statement. Question 2: Did Hamid Mir inform his top
management about these threats and the likely perpetrators?
Answer:
Yes, he had conveyed in writing to the management that decided not to
make it public unless the situation demanded so. His email on February
25, 2014 (2:15pm) to Geo TV management said all about that Amir Mir
disclosed on Geo TV attributing it as statement of Hamid Mir. Other than
learning through Hamid Mir, the management was aware of the precarious
situation through the threatening messages received from other quarters
about the victim journalist in the past.
Question 3: Will the emails be made public?
Answer: They will be presented as evidence to support the allegations before the judicial commission .
Question 4: Was Hamid Mir the only person from Geo TV facing threats?
Answer:
Many others are also under threat. Included among them Question 5:
Isn’t it unfair to accuse ISI chief without any solid evidence?
Answer:
All Pakistanis respect the national security institutions and their
sensitivity is kept in mind. That said the individuals working for the
agencies were not immune from criminal investigation by any legal
standard. Also the fact remains that investigation into a crime starts
from the suspicion. The first question asked by the police to victim
side is: who do you suspect? The purpose is to get to the culprits. .
Question 6: What if ISI chief’s involvement is not established?
Answer:
That will be good news and remove dust of suspicions. It is rather a
golden opportunity for ISI to come out clean by offering able assistance
to the investigators in getting to the culprits given the capability
and a lot of resources at its disposal. The ISI and MI had successfully
done this job after the assassination attempt on former President Gen
Pervez Musharraf. They apprehended the rogue elements within the forces
that were hands in glove with the militant organisations in this killing
plot.
Question 7: Was it fair to flash repeatedly the photo of ISI chief on Geo TV?
Answer: Let me ask a counter question. Don’t media flash pictures when some other noted figures are held accused in any case?
There
is no news on TV carried either without graphics or pictures. The
picture shown was not the only photo of ISI chief available. Several
were about the ISI headquarters and others related to the agency. Since
ISI chief was being accused, not the agency overall, hence only his
picture was flashed.
Moreover it is recognized legal right of the family of any victim of an attack to name suspects.
Hamid Mir had also conveyed this to some of his friends.
and investigative agencies
are senior journalists of the Group and complaint in this regard was lodged with the government and its institutions.
ISI chief has to face the judicial commission now
On
different occasions when allegations were leveled against the then COAS
Musharraf, the then ISI chief Shuja Pasha, Premier Nawaz Sharif, Chief
Minister Shahbaz Sharif, former President Asif Ali Zardari, PTI chief
Imran Khan, former PM Yusuf Raza Gilani and former PM Raja Peraiz
Ashraf, the pictures of all these leaders were shown along with the
allegations repeatedly by electronic media. When Benazir Bhutto accused
the then President Musharraf, the then IB chief Brigadier Ijaz and the
then Punjab CM Pervaiz Ilahi of conspiring to murder her, the pictures
of all them were repeatedly shown by the electronic media. When the
PML-N had accused the then ISI chief Shuja Pasha of backing Imran Khan
and demanded his resignation, the PML-N demand and accusation along with
Pasha’s picture were repeatedly shown on the electronic media.
Moreover,
when reports about any blast, price hike, power outages, accident,
police action against protesters and any unjustice with masses are
aired, related pictures are also repeatedly shown on TV screens.
This
should not be considered as a conspiracy. If pattern and behaviour of
electronic media is properly understood, question of any conspiracy
won’t come into mind. Is it not a fact that if any journalist is killed,
the scene of the incident is shown repeatedly. The electronic media did
not spare Iftikhar Muhammad Chaudhary before he retired as chief
justice. The allegations on sitting judges were also aired by the media.
Thousands of channels in India, US and UK enjoy maximum
freedom. If it is complained in Pakistan that agency chief’s coverage
was wrong, then the coverage of the issues related to civilians is also
wrong. The electronic media airs beepers and holds talk shows in
accordance with the importance of the issue. The similar pattern was
adopted on this issue.
Question 8: Why is there such hue and cry over coverage of this issue?
Because
in our country there is a concept of sacred cow and untouchables about
the very powerful. Allegations have been leveled in the past also but
this time they came with a bang. Or perhaps because Jang Group is the
biggest media group the issue had generate so much hue and cry.
Whatever
is highlighted in this context is done in accordance with the
constitution and law. Those who are leveling criticism they will soon
know that the coverage of this incident was in accordance with
constitution and law. The coverage was meant to uphold supremacy of
constitution, freedom of press and rule of law. Media gurus know that
this box (TV) in the world has its own dynamics and it continues to earn
its independence.
It should be noted that Jang Group
alone and also along with journalists had moved courts and Supreme Court
with the pray to regulate media. Hamid Mir and Absar Alim, who remained
with the Jang Group, had also moved court in this regard. But this is
unfortunate that courts have not moved fast, nor the government had paid
attention to it.
Jang Group had also been asking the
government to regulate media. This is Jang Group’s official stand. The
prime minister and information minister are witness to it.
Question 9: Did Geo TV take version of ISI?
Answer:
As the allegations levelled by Amir Mir were aired, it followed a
clarification from the ISPR. Where ISI chief’s picture was flashed
together with the allegations raised against him, there was ISPR
clarification run with the picture of DG ISPR Maj Gen Asim Saleem Bajwa.
Question 10: Did ISI or ISPR complain to Geo over running the picture?
Answer:
Neither of them contacted the management hence no objection was raised.
Carrying the news and dropping it later on was the sole decision of Geo
TV without any external intervention. This issue was only raised
through opinion-makers aligned with national security agencies.
Question 11: Why ISI chief was asked to resign?
Answer:
This demand was not made by the organization. This was the stand of one
of the senior most journalists of the Jang Group who is among the most
credible newsmen of the country. The opposite view of his stand from
within and outside the Group was also aired