GENEVA: The
lineup of Gulf royalty at the Islamabad international airport is not
the only sign of a major realignment in the region.
During
a skirmish between the envoys of the United States and China in the
general debate at the United Nations Human Rights Council this week, the
Saudi envoy sided with Beijing and locked horns with Washington. So did
Pakistan and a host of other countries.
Iran remained silent.
The
colourful anti-clerical Iranian opposition groups that used to enrich
the international s scene on the sidelines of UNHRC in Geneva until last
year have disappeared this year. Has their financial support dried up?
Nobody knows. They have been replaced by NGOs promoting a new positive
image of Iran. For example, this week, one NGO held an event on Iran’s
positive treatment of women, minorities and the progress in the lives of
Iranian Sunni Baloch. The presentations were impressive and convincing.
The
other area where change is noticeable is the mushrooming of NGOs
attacking Iran’s traditional political competition in the region: Saudi
Arabia, Bahrain, Egypt, and more recently Malaysia. Pakistan is in this
list with repeated side panel discussions organised this week by
apparently Iran-linked NGOs to assail the treatment of Shia minorities
in these countries. This year, there is a sharp focus on Pakistan and
Malaysia. At least one event has been organised on this topic outside
the UN building and two inside, with paid guests flown in from both
countries to speak and criticise their governments.
Though
the criticism of Saudi Arabia, Bahrain, Malaysia and sometimes Egypt is
blunt and direct, the criticism on Pakistan by Iran-linked NGOs varies
from mild to slightly harsh, but at all times calibrated. Last week,
when a couple of questioners asked a female Pakistani speaker to name
Pakistani government and military as alleged supporters of terror groups
that attack Pakistani Shia citizens, the speaker refused to be drawn
into a debate. “I will only talk about the cases in front of me and the
groups involved,” she said. ‘I have no evidence on the involvement of
Pakistani government or military.”
The fact that
Iran-linked groups are organising seminars inside the UN building
putting Pakistan on trial for the human rights situation in the country
could at some point irk Islamabad, which has so far unreservedly
extended diplomatic and political support to Tehran inside and outside
the UN.
Malaysia, by comparison, is not that recalcitrant.
Azhaan Hamid, a member of a Malaysian NGO, explained there is no
restriction on the practice of Shia Muslim sect in his country. “We
welcome all Muslims.
We traditionally never had Shia
Muslim presence. But now one country is paying money to create presence
for political purposes, not religious,” he said, without naming Iran.The
subject is sensitive and difficult to probe because it involves
religious sensibilities. But here the issue is political, where states
are involved with their strategic interests, exploiting religion. During
another sideline event on Iraq, a speaker called on all Muslim states
to stop using sects to further strategic interests.
Mehdi
al-Katib, from the al-Khoei Foundation, named after the revered Iraqi
Shia scholar whose disciples are spread in many countries including
Pakistan, agrees. “I agree with the argument. Muslim states should not
use sects as a tool of politics or strategy.”
For the
first time this year, a young man has been seen at different panel
discussions claiming to represent Pakistani Hazaras.Though the plight of
our Hazaras is real and indescribable, the young man appeared to be
politicising it, and offered anti-Pakistan lobbies to take up the topic
of Pakistani government allegedly condoning attacks on its citizens who
follow the Shia sect. Interestingly, Alessandro Monsutti, an
anthropologist with The Graduate Institute in Geneva, was in the
audience. He intervened to correct the record. He said Pakistan’s
Hazaras were accepted wholeheartedly into the Pakistani fabric since
1947, and produced national heroes in civil life and in the military,
and that the attacks on the community were largely a post-2001 Afghan
war development.
Pakistan is preparing to table a
resolution against the unchecked use of unmanned drones at UNHRC with
wide international support.Pakistan is also pushing the Kashmir dispute
with a new vigour. The backlash is visible, with increased activity in
Geneva on Balochistan, and the speakers flown in from several countries
to speak about the secession of different Pakistani provinces. While
Islamabad understands this backlash, the entry of the sectarian element
is a new development, and a disturbing one.