ISLAMABAD:
All retired judges of the Federal Shariat Court are in danger of being
deprived of their pension as the AGPR thinks the recent advice of the
law ministry in the case of Chief Justice of Federal Shariat Court may
be applicable to all former judges of the court.
Thus
the ministry seems to have opened a Pandora’s box by saying that the
judges of the Federal Shariat Court are not entitled to pension and
other such benefits.The AGPR is in a state of shock as several retired
judges of the FSC have been drawing pension for years but now it has
been revealed that these judges are not entitled to it.
The
authorities in the AGPR are now collecting the information about all
such retired judges to get their pensions suspended till certain
questions raised by the law ministry’s advice are clarified.The sources
said that the decision had been taken in the AGPR to suspend the pension
of the incumbent CJ FSC and all those retired judges of the FSC who are
currently drawing pensions.
Since such retired judges are
being paid pensions from different regional offices of the AGPR,
therefore, it has been decided to collect the details about all these
judges first and then approach the National Bank of Pakistan to stop
processing these pensions.
The AGPR had referred the case
of Chief Justice of Federal Shariat Court Agha Rafiq Ahmad Khan, who was
drawing salary as well as pension for the post that he is still
holding.Responding to the AGPR’s query, the law ministry said that the
judges of the FSC, including its chief justice, are contract employees
and therefore not entitled to post-retirement benefits.
“It
is clarified that since the appointment of the chief justices and that
of judges of Federal Shariat Court have a fixed term or terms these are
contract appointments and contractual appointments do not confer
continuity in service which is the basis of retirement and
post-retirement benefits, therefore, the aforesaid judges are not
entitled to post-retirement benefits, including pension,” the law
ministry had told the AGPR.
The issue for the AGPR,
Islamabad, was whether under the law it was possible for the incumbent
Chief Justice Federal Shariat Court Justice Agha Rafiq Ahmad Khan to
draw both pension and salary of the office of the FSC CJ at the same
time.
Justice Agha’s “pension payment order” shows him
retiring as the FSC Chief Justice on June 4, 2011, when he had actually
completed his two-year tenure, which was extended for another three
years ending in June this year. However, he never took a fresh oath.
Regarding
the CJ FSC’s pension, the law ministry had referred to the clause (4)
of Article 230C of the Constitution which says that the Chief Justice
and a Judge shall hold office for a period not exceeding three years,
but may be appointed for such further term or terms as the President may
determine.
“This provision abundantly manifests that the
appointment of the chief justice and a judge of Federal Shariat Court is
of contractual nature and is not regular appointment leading to
retirement because in case of judges of the apex court Article 179 of
the Constitution and in respect of judge of high court Article 195 of
the Constitution provide for retirement of judges but no such provision
exists in the Constitution regarding the retirement of the chief justice
and the judge of the Federal Shariat Court,” the law ministry’s advice
had conveyed to the AGPR.
The AGPR had sought advice in
the CJ FSC’s case only but the law ministry’s advice has now engulfed
all the retired judges of the Federal Shariat Court.
The
AGPR is puzzled that the retired judges of the Federal Shariat Court
have been given pension following the notifications issued by the law
ministry, which has now come up with the explanation that the judges of
the FSC are contractual appointees and, therefore, not entitled to
pensionary benefits.