LONDON: The
former president of the International Cricket Council (ICC) and a
senior Pakistan Cricket Board (PCB) adviser Ehsan Mani has said that
Najam Sethi, ex-PCB chairman, had nothing to do with the bidding
procedures or sports rights for the cricket series against Sri Lanka.
Geo
TV’s detractors and Najam Sethi’s critics, without presenting any
evidence, have alleged that Sethi, who hosts one of the most watched
current affairs shows on Geo called ‘Aapas Ki Baat’, may have helped Geo
Super get the sporting rights for the Pakistan-Sri Lanka series held in
the United Arab Emirates last year.
But in an exclusive
interview over phone with this correspondent from France, Ehsan Mani,
who was the head of the PCB committee that approved the Geo Sports’ bid
for the Sri Lanka/South Africa series, expressed shock that such
baseless allegations were aired without giving any thought to the facts.
Ehsan
Mani is a board member of Imran Khan’s Shaukat Khanum Memorial Hospital
and a friend of Imran Khan — who has led the campaign of allegations
against the Jang and Geo Group, accusing the group of being involved in
election rigging and winning favours from Nawaz Sharif — but Mani said
he was astonished that such allegations were being made knowingly by
some whose aim was to malign rather than to do anything good.
But
the stern rebuttal by Ehsan Mani will come as a shock to Imran Khan who
faces court cases from Jang and Geo over these allegations.
Ehsan
Mani clarified: “The committee that I headed comprised Justice Shabbar
Rizvi, an ex-Lahore High Court judge, Ahmed Hussain and a lawyer. It had
three PCB management members Subhan Ahmed, COO, Badar Khan, CFO, and
Salman Naseer, PCB’s internal legal adviser. It has had an ex-PCB Board
member Bughio, a close aide of Zaka Ashraf.
“It was on my
request that renowned accounting firmErnst & Young was taken on
board to oversee all the process and to ensure that the whole bidding
process was independent and transparent. The aim was to ensure
transparency so that no bidder should be given undue advantage. Ernst
and Young made the final report with recommendations and sent it to the
PCB.”
Ehsan Mani said that the highest bidders were Ten
Sports and Geo and they were recommended on the basis of the merit of
their bids, the highest amounts they put down to win these rights.
“Najam Sethi wasn’t involved at any stage. He had nothing to do with the
bidding at any of the stages. There was only one PCB representative
Bughio who sat in the meeting as an observer. Najam Sethi didn’t have
any influence at any stage. There was no pressure, corruption or
manipulation. Everything was independent and the bid was open,
negotiations were opened and on board. Everything was on record and
minutes were taken down.”
After the bids were received,
Mani said, the committee only recommended to the PCB board that the
South African series shall go to Ten Sports and the rights for Sri Lanka
shall go to Geo Super. “We had no power other than to make
recommendations. The PCB governing body finalised the decision. There
was no interference at all at any level, there’s no question of any
pressure. It was not possible. The highest bidder won and it’s simple.
The terms and conditions were provided in writing in advance to all the
parties involved.”
Ehsan Mani refused to disclose how much
money was offered by Geo Super and Ten Sports because it was
“confidential” but he stressed that the rights were won by the highest
and the most competitive bidders. “There is no doubt about that. This is
all on the record. Ernst & Young witnessed the negotiations and
recorded everything. Their report was confidential and private which we
didn’t see. Everyone involved was satisfied with the procedures and no
objections were raised.”
When asked if the chairman PCB
could manipulate at any stage using his powers, Ehsan Mani said that the
process of establishing committees was such that the chairman couldn’t
do anything. “The PCB chairman cannot manipulate. When I was approached
to be a part of this committee, I said I will help.”
Mani
said that he has been helping the Pakistan cricket since 1992 and had
been involved in many deals and at various stages. “My only condition
was that this committee will be independent and the PCB chairman will
not be involved. The committee was completely independent and any
involvement from any quarter was out of the question. I had done the ICC
deal for $500 million in 2000. In 2006 and 2007, I was asked again by
the ICC to help with their rights and one of the deals was done for $1.1
billion. When my reputation is so high and I am trusted so much, then
why would I do anything untoward?”
When asked again if
Najam Sethi had anything to do with the bidding process, Ehsan Mani said
that Najam Sethi had no involvement. “Najam Sethi had absolutely no
involvement. He couldn’t have done that. We followed a transparent
procedure. No bidder knew who was offering what amount. No one knew what
was on board. We wanted maximum money. We wanted maximum money for the
PCB and that was our aim. Those who failed our targets failed to get the
rights. All bidders were there and they knew what was going on.”
Ehsan
Mani’s interview has proved the allegation leveled by Imran Khan,
Mubashir Luqman and several TV channels as a complete lie. Several
channels, particularly ARY, were alleging that Sethi favoured Geo in
getting the cricket rights. Imran Khan leveled this allegation in his
several TV interviews. He particularly attended Mubashir Luqman’s
programme at ARY and repeatedly leveled this baseless allegation.
The
Jang Group’s response to this allegation was present at its website,
parts of social media and even published several times in newspapers,
but no anchorperson ever asked any question from Imran Khan about the
role and stand of Ehsan Mani, who is the chairman of the audit committee
of Shaukat Khanum Hospital.
As Imran’s allegation has
been proven a lie, the lawyers community in the UK is discussing what
would be the worth of Imran’s other allegations against the Geo and Jang
Group. They think Imran, who enjoys respect in the UK, will face
embarrassment on failure to prove his charges against the Geo/Jang Group
in the UK courts.