Showing posts with label criticise. Show all posts
Showing posts with label criticise. Show all posts

Thursday, 12 June 2014

Senators criticise metro bus project, laptop scheme



 












ISLAMABAD: Senators across the aisle on Wednesday objected to the Rawalpindi metro bus project and laptop scheme and called for concrete policies and sufficient allocations of funds to fight terrorism, poverty and increasing joblessness.
One senator complained that the spending on water reservoirs was equal to the funds earmarked for the metro bus project while another Rs55 billion had been allocated for the Lahore-Karachi Motorway. The government was asked to instead complete the Lowari Tunnel project as soon as possible. The government was criticised for missing out on almost all the macro-economic targets, as reflected in the Economic Survey 2013-14. The senators laid emphasis on more allocations for building water reservoirs.

The House offered Fateha for the departed soul of Nawab Khair Bakhsh Marri and paid tributes to the veteran Baloch leader for his services for democracy and the rights of the people of Balochistan.

Taking part in the budget debate, former provincial finance minister and leader of the Awami National Party Senator Haji Muhammad Adeel proposed that all employees of military, the judiciary, civil servants and private employees, including doctors, lawyers and FBR officers, must file their tax returns.

“The FBR officers who decline to file their returns should be suspended and put in jails. How can they ask others to pay taxes when they themselves don’t do so?” he asserted. He questioned the government’s claim of presenting a pro-poor budget and noted that while duty on 1800cc car had been withdrawn, motorbike parts had been taxed.

The senator reminded the government former premier Shaukat Aziz had promised to release Rs62 billion for lift I and lift III of the Chashma Right Canal but this was never released after it was proved that the Punjab had charged water tax from farmers for the water supply provided by the Khyber-Pakhtunkhwa free of cost.

He said that if efforts to crush terrorism in the Khyber-Pakhtunkhwa failed, then people would have two options: either to grow long beard and join the Taliban ranks or migrate to the Punjab and other provinces as IDPs.

Adeel painted a grim security picture of Peshawar and other parts of the province and challenged Imran Khan to bring back his sons and get them admitted to the best provincial school and stay in Peshawar himself for a month to understand how serious the law and order situation was.

He said as against Rs110 billion arrears in the context of net hydel profit from 1990-91 to 2004-05, the federal government should pay Rs56 billion as interest to the Khyber-Pakhtunkhwa. He regretted that the capped net Rs6 billion hydel profit had not been paid to the province for the last one year.

Senator Muzaffar Hussain Shah of PML-Functional urged the government to sign a separate agreement with India for the protection of Pakistani farmers’ interests. He wanted fiscal powers for the Senate that existed even at the time of Basic Democracy and said this was vital to strengthening the system and making the Federation viable.

The senator contended that senators should also be given representation in the Public Accounts Committee to oversee the implementation of the budget. He also proposed the formation of joint parliamentary standing committees of key ministries for quality legislation and saving time, as was done in India.

He disputed the perception that parliament was supreme and recalled the House privilege committee had summoned a senior officer five times, but he had declined to oblige. “There is nothing in the budget for the 50 percent Pakistanis, who are poor. Moreover, there has not been enough increase in the salaries of the government employees while inflation has increased massively,” said Senator Abdul Rauf of the Pakhtunkhwa Milli Awami Party.

He called for the revival of the Quetta-Zhob rail service to solve the travel problem of hundreds of thousands of people. He noted no uplift steps had been mentioned in the budget for the smaller provinces.

PPP’s Usman Saifullah pointed out that the stability of Pak rupee was made possible only after obtaining loans from abroad. He claimed two families had 18 percent shares in the Karachi Stock Exchange and there had been 1-2 billion dollars increase in their income.

He reminded the ruling PML-N it was mentioned in its manifesto that a separate energy ministry would be established but there had been no progress in this context even after a year.

Senator Talha Mehmood of the JUI-F claimed that massive landsliding was being witnessed in the Mian Charr village and the Geological Survey of Pakistan had called for immediate evacuation of the population and for building of concrete walls to prevent a disaster even bigger than the Attaabad Lake.

PPP’s Dr. Karim Khawaja said the burden of fiscal deficit had been shifted to the salaried class while relief had been given to the affluent. He said the budget lacked any strategy to fighting poverty and joblessness.

Thursday, 24 April 2014

Army men used to criticise ISI but faced no treason charges


 
ISLAMABAD: Though many media men and journalists are out to prove that Hamid Mir, Geo and Jang Group are traitors merely because Hamid Mir had alleged before the attack on him that he will be attacked by the ISI chief and some other ISI individuals, there are countless examples where regular army officials, even a sitting ISI chief, made more serious allegations against the prime intelligence agency but were never declared traitors.
Geo and Jang Group have repeatedly issued statements that they have the highest regard for all institutions. Despite the fact that Hamid Mir was hundred percent convinced that he will be attacked, the channel only aired the news after he was attacked informing the people what the assessment of Hamid Mir was without giving a final judgment as to who carried out the attack.

Was Hamid Mir the only one to point out some problems or some rogue elements within the ISI? No. There are many from within the armed forces, even former DG ISI Lt Gen Ahmad Shuja Pasha and many retired officers including former COAS Gen (retd) Pervez Musharraf, who clearly hinted at grave problems within the intelligence outfit. Many experts have termed such revelations as “ISI within ISI” and analysed that apparently these “rogue” elements are stronger and influential.

It is also an important point that politicians, bureaucrats, and everyone is attacked and criticised for anything but few people consider generals as “sacred cow”, over and above any criticism despite the fact that they are involved in violence against innocent citizens. Reports of judicial commissions establish the involvement of ISI elements in such violent activities. The biggest office of the state is the office of the president and even it is never spared from criticism.

It was Ahmad Shuja Pasha who at the time of his appearance before the Abbottabad Commission confessed that “ISI had brutalised many decent people”. However, Pasha had added, “ISI mindset, culture and methodology were changing.” Before this Abbottabad Commission, Pasha slammed former army chief Gen (retd) Pervez Musharraf for bowing down to the Americans.

Pasha had disclosed that Musharraf had caved in to the US so promptly that the Shamsi airbase was given to them for drone strikes in Pakistan. Pasha was made to confess before the Abbottabad Commission that the Abbottabad incident was the result of lack of capacity, inadequate knowledge and wrong attitude. Pasha had even admitted of enforced disappearances, notwithstanding the fact the ISI had no detention powers.

While many in the media are trying to unnecessarily defend the ISI and are not ready to admit that correct criticism will help the institution improve, Pasha’s statement endorses report of the Umar Cheema Commission that the agency remained involved in terrible things like kidnappings and torturing citizens.

When Pasha said so, it was not treason but when Hamid Mir said the same on the basis of credible information, it is treason despite the fact that he is admitted in hospital after sustaining six bullets and is unable to walk.

Gen (retd) Musharraf in his 2011 interview with ABC in USA said, “It is possible that rogue members of the Inter-Services Intelligence (ISI) and the military knew of Osama bin Laden’s hideout in Abbottabad.

“As a policy, the army and the ISI are fighting terrorism and extremism, al Qaeda and the Taliban. But rogue elements within are a possibility.“As I said, at the lower level, somebody (could be) following a policy of his own and violating the policy from above is a possibility.”

Top army officials have admitted that when Musharraf was attacked twice, some ISI officials were involved. But it was not treason as though it was hundred percent proved and these incidents killed many individuals.

These statements proved the existence of rogue elements within the ISI and pointing out this fact would have helped the ISI improve and cleanse its ranks of such elements.Former minister of state for religious affairs Dr Amir Liaquat Hussain stated on May 5, 2005 that then President Musharraf had faced threats from within. He had elaborated that some elements from within the institutions could attack to kill the former army chief. But it was not treason though the role of ISI “individuals” was clearly pointed out.

If there are rogue elements within the ISI or any other institution, they could be mentioned, criticised and blamed. There are no holy cows which could never be touched even if found involved in illegal activities or highhandedness against innocent civilian citizens. When any official of such a disciplined institute is involved in any such activity, the head of the organisation is always blamed as it is incomprehensible that he is not in the picture. A senior journalist, during a private meeting, tried to inquire from Pasha about the involvement of his agency’s officials in kidnapping and torturing Umar Cheema. Pasha was unable to deny but failed to deliver a direct response.

The Judicial Commission has concluded that the role of agencies in the Umar Cheema case was eminent.Keeping aside Pakistan, any wrongdoings of intelligence agencies are highlighted, questioned and criticised in civilised world by professional journalists. In the USA, the American media exposed CIA’s many wrongdoings, including the worst i.e. desecration of Holy Quran in Guantanamo Bay. Majority of the US people who have respect and dignity get united against the American government and elite intelligence agency CIA and get many wrongs reversed.

However, in Pakistan Hamid Mir’s own friends in the media are letting him down, so discussing his opponents is not important. Even in India, the independent Indian media used to expose scandals against its own army and a shameful scandal was reported about the Indian Army chief in recent years. All this brought improvements in those institutions of India. But all this is treason here in Pakistan and consequently the situation and professional excellence of security institutions is also not hidden from anyone.

Not only top army officials made such allegations against the ISI with all proofs and certainty but even top politicians did so but that was never treason. Pakistan’s present interior minister and the then leader of the opposition Chaudhry Nisar Ali Khan made speeches taking the name of DG ISI and alleging him of involvement in illegal and unconstitutional activities. In his interview with Hamid Mir in Capital Talk, Nisar has even said that DG ISI Ahmad Shuja Pasha was making and strengthening a political party – PTI. He never gave any evidence but that was not treason. Today Nisar says he has never seen anyone making allegation this way in the entire world.

Wednesday, 26 March 2014

Former Pakistan cricketers criticise Bangladesh flag ban





KARACHI: Former Pakistani players hit out after Bangladesh banned their own fans from waving non-Bangladeshi flags at the ongoing World Twenty20 tournament.

Hosts Bangladesh issued the order after an outcry over images of locals waving Pakistani flags during the recent Asia Cup.

The Bangladesh Cricket Board (BCB) made the ruling on Tuesday, on the eve of the country’s 44th Independence Day.

Former Pakistan captain Javed Miandad said the move violated the spirit of the game.

“I am surprised at the decision,” Miandad told AFP. “Cricket is a game which harbours sportsman spirit and this decision violates that spirit.”

Another former captain, Mohammad Yousuf, urged the BCB to rethink.

“I am sure that the BCB will take this decision back because it defies logic and I am sure the International Cricket Council will seek some explanation,” Yousuf said.

Yousuf, who played 90 Tests and 288 ODIs for Pakistan, said he had always been warmly received in Bangladesh.

“I have seen the home fans want to support Pakistan whenever their own team is not competing against us,” he said.

Younis Khan, another former captain, agreed Bangladesh should reconsider their decision.

“It is against the spirit of the game as you cannot stop anyone from supporting his favourite team,” he said.

Bangladesh and Pakistan face each other in a potentially crucial World T20 group match in Mirpur on Sunday.