Showing posts with label debate. Show all posts
Showing posts with label debate. Show all posts

Saturday, 3 May 2014

Edward Snowden appears via video at Toronto debate

A file image (made from video) of former National Security Agency contractor Edward Snowden.
 
AP A file image (made from video) of former National Security Agency contractor Edward Snowden.
Edward Snowden, the former U.S. intelligence contractor who has been leaking information about government data collection programs, says entire populations, rather than just individuals, now live under constant surveillance.
Mr. Snowden appeared via video link at Toronto’s Roy Thomson Hall during a Munk Debate about state surveillance on Friday night.
Former U.S. National Security Administration director General Michael Hayden and well-known civil liberties lawyer and Harvard law professor Alan M. Dershowitz, argued in favour of the debate statement — “Be it resolved state surveillance is a legitimate defence of our freedoms.”
Glenn Greenwald, the journalist whose work based on the Mr. Snowden leaks won a Pulitzer Prize last month and Alexis Ohanian, the co-founder of social media website reddit, were in opposition.
The debate ended with 59 percent of the audience siding with Mr. Greenwald and Mr. Ohanian.

Monday, 10 March 2014

NSA leaks fuelled needed debate on spying: Snowden

imageWASHINGTON: Former intelligence contractor Edward Snowden said on Monday he has no regrets over his leaks about mass surveillance programs, saying they sparked a needed public debate on spying and data collection.
Snowden, who spoke via video link from Russia to the SXSW festival in Austin, Texas, said he revealed the programs of the US National Security Agency and other such services to foster "a better civic understanding" about what had been secret programs.
He said his decision to leak documents to journalists "wasn't so I could single handedly change the government; what I wanted to do was inform the public so they could provide their consent to what we should do."
Snowden, a former NSA contractor who has been in hiding in Russia and has been charged in the United States with espionage, maintained that "every society in the world has benefited" from the debate on surveillance.
"Regardless of what happens to me, this is something we have a right to know," he said on the link with members of the American Civil Liberties Union, who noted that the hookup was routed through seven proxy servers to keep his location secure.
Snowden, who appeared against a backdrop of a giant copy of the US constitution, said the NSA programs have fundamentally altered the rights outlined in the charter.
"The interpretation of the constitution has been changed from 'no unreasonable searches and seizures,' to 'any seizure is fine, just don't search it,'" he said.
Snowden said he chose to speak to SXSW because he believes it is important to encourage technology companies to make changes to stem mass surveillance.
"The people who are in the room in Austin right now, they are the folks who can really fix things through technical standards," he said.
Snowden said more companies should adopt robust encryption that is built into communications without users having to use complex technical tools.
He maintained that if encryption is too complex, "people aren't going to use it; it has to happen automatically, it has to happen seamlessly."
If online communications are fully encrypted at all stages, Snowden said, bulk data collection would become too difficult for intelligence agencies.
He also said the NSA and other agencies have devoted too many resources to this type of bulk collection and not enough to traditional methods to catch criminals and terrorists.
"We've had tremendous intelligence failures because we are monitoring everybody's communications, instead of suspects," he said.
He cited the Boston marathon bombings as an example, saying "if we hadn't spent so much on mass surveillance, if we followed traditional models, we might have caught" the suspects.
Congress needs watchdog:
One of the questions came via Twitter from Tim Berners-Lee, creator of the World Wide Web, who thanked Snowden and asked how to make an intelligence oversight system more accountable.
Snowden said "the key factor is accountability" and that Congress needed a watchdog because it failed to adequately oversee the NSA.
"We can't have officials who can lie to the Congress and not face any consequences," he said. "We need a watchdog that watches Congress."
Documents leaked by Snowden in 2013 revealed widespread surveillance of individuals and institutions in the United States and around the world.
He received temporary asylum in Russia in August a move that infuriated the United States and was a key factor behind President Barack Obama's decision to cancel a summit with counterpart Vladimir Putin last year.

Tuesday, 4 March 2014

Obama budget sets up election-year debate with Republicans


imageWASHINGTON: President Barack Obama proposed new tax credits and job-training programs for US workers on Tuesday in a 2015 budget that highlights stark differences with Republicans, who favor a reduced government role in promoting economic opportunity.
The election-year blueprint is all but certain to be rejected by the Republican-controlled House of Representatives and stands little chance of passage.
But it sets out the Democratic president's policy priorities ahead of November congressional elections, in which his party hopes to keep control of the US Senate and avoid losing ground in the House.
The blueprint for the 2015 fiscal year that begins on Oct. 1 would increase tax credits for the working poor, boost spending on roads and bridges and expand early-childhood education.
Obama's proposal signals a shift away from last year's emphasis on deficit cutting to a greater focus on fighting poverty, a goal the president is highlighting as he faces less than three years left in office.
The debate over Obama's controversial healthcare reform law is likely to feature prominently in the elections, but poverty reduction and Americans' slow recovery from the 2007-2009 recession are also likely to be major themes.
House Budget Committee Chairman Paul Ryan, a potential Republican presidential contender in 2016, argued in a report on Monday that the government had barely made a dent in combating poverty over the past 50 years despite massive spending.
Obama and Ryan disagree on the role government should play in poverty reduction, but they both back the Earned Income Tax Credit, an anti-poverty measure that is meant to encourage low-income Americans to continue working.
Obama's budget proposes expanding the program to cover some 13.5 million people who do not have children. It would also make the program available to younger workers who are not currently eligible.
"The EITC for families with children lifts millions out of poverty each year and helps about half of all parents at some point in their lives," Obama wrote in his budget document.
"But as a number of prominent policymakers, both progressive and conservative, have noted, the EITC does not do enough for single workers who do not have kids."
The expansion, which would cost $60 billion, would be funded by closing loopholes such as the tax break for "carried interest," profits earned by wealthy investors who run private equity and other funds. Obama has long sought to end that tax break, which allows financiers to treat such income as capital gains, making it subject to a tax rate of only 20 percent, instead of the nearly 40 percent top rate on ordinary income paid by the highest earners.
Representative Dave Camp, the Republican chairman of the powerful House Ways and Means Committee, also proposed last month to "clean up" the carried interest deduction, but tax reform is not expected to get traction in Congress this year.
SAVINGS, NO OLIVE BRANCH:
Obama will unveil the document during a visit to a local elementary school, giving him a chance to highlight the proposal's emphasis on boosting funding for education, which has gotten little support from opposition lawmakers.
The White House signaled last month that its new budget would not extend the olive branch to Republicans that was offered in its proposal a year ago.
Obama dropped a suggestion to change how the government calculates inflation for Social Security and other federal benefits that could have led to income drops for older Americans.
The proposed cost-of-living change, which was unpopular with Obama's Democratic allies, was meant to show Republicans the president was serious about deficit reduction. White House officials said Obama abandoned it after Republicans declined to offer concessions of their own.
Overall, Obama's proposed budget for 2015 would spend $3.9 trillion, leading to a $564 billion budget deficit, or 3.1 percent of the nation's gross domestic product. That would be down from a $649 billion deficit, or 3.7 percent of GDP, in fiscal year 2014.