Showing posts with label followed. Show all posts
Showing posts with label followed. Show all posts

Thursday, 10 April 2014

Former CJ followed Constitution: SC

ISLAMABAD: The Supreme Court (SC) on Thursday, while announcing a detailed judgment in the review petition of former president General (retd) Pervez Musharraf against its July 31, 2009 verdict, ruled that former chief justice (CJ) Iftikhar Muhammad Chaudhry followed the Constitution and the army chief had no jurisdiction to impose emergency in the country on Nov 3, 2007.

The SC ruled that the judgment under review did not stand vitiated by any bias or error in law or fact to warrant a review.A 42-page judgment, authored by Chief Justice Tassaduq Hussain Jillani, ruled that the power of review could not be invoked as a routine matter to rehear a case which had already been decided nor change of a counsel would warrant sustaining of a review petition, but the same could be pressed into service where a glaring omission or patent mistake had crept in earlier by judicial fallibility.

“If the court has taken a conscious and deliberate decision on a point of fact or law, a review petition will not lie,” the judgment says.The court ruled that it had narrated with a measure of dismay the frequent constitutional deviations in the country. “The spirit which underpins the judgment is a strong realisation that we should not remain trapped by mistakes in history and turn a new leaf towards constitutionalism and the rule of law,” says the detailed verdict.

The court observed that the declarations and findings of July 31, 2009 judgment could not be a subject matter of review as neither there was any discovery of new or important matter or evidence which after the “exercise of due diligence” was not within the knowledge of the petitioner or could not be produced by him at the time when the judgment under challenge was passed.

The court observed that in fact, the petitioner’s learned counsel frankly admitted, on court query, first that the then prime minister Shaukat Aziz had written a letter to the President of Pakistan and not to the Chief of the Army Staff; second that the prime minister had not advised him to impose the state of emergency rather “the petitioner acted in his own discretion”.

“This frank admission by his counsel has further weakened his case for review,” the detailed verdict ruled questioning as how the petitioner in his capacity as chief of army staff or even as president could act on his own discretion.

“He had no power under the law to impose the state of emergency and make judges of the Supreme Court and high courts dysfunctional notwithstanding the mandate of Article 48 of the Constitution,” says the judgment.

Justice Jawad S Khawaja, in his additional note, observed that the proclamation of emergency, it would be seen, did not target the former chief justice alone as it targeted the judiciary of the country.

He said that much was clear even from a cursory reading of the text of the proclamation of emergency and the advice of the prime minister which was purportedly relied upon by the petitioner in taking his actions of Nov 3, 2007.He said, “We must remain cognizant of a central tenet of the rule of law, that the law must widely be accessible to the public.”

Former president General (retd) Pervez Musharraf had filed a review petition against the court judgment of July 31, 2009, declaring the steps taken on Nov 3, 2007 including imposing the emergency rule in the country as illegal and unconstitutional.

A full court on January 30, 2014, while hearing the review petition of the former military dictator for three days, dismissed it. “We find the review petition filed by General (retd) Pervez Musharraf was time barred and the precedent case law cited in this behalf was distinguishable,” the court ruled in its short order.

The court further ruled that the grounds urged by the petitioner’s learned counsel neither fell within the purview of review jurisdiction nor tenable on merit to warrant interference in the judgment under challenge.

Friday, 4 April 2014

Blind being followed in the name of talks: Bilawal



 












GARHI KHUDA BAKHSH: PPP Chairman Bilawal Bhutto Zardari on Friday said sighted persons were asking the blind to lead them in the name of talks, adding that his party would not bow down to savages and tolerate their dictatorship.
Addressing a public gathering at Garhi Khuda Bakhsh on the occasion of the 35th death anniversary of the party founder Zulfikar Ali Bhutto, Bilawal said the Taliban were deceiving everyone in the name of talks. He said the negotiations were being held with those who had termed Quaid-e-Azam ‘Kafir-e-Azam’.

“Those who leveled allegations against the PPP are politicking over children’s bodies,” he added. Bilawal alleged that Prime Minister Muhammad Nawaz Sharif only issued statements and made false promises when he visited Tharparkar. He claimed the premier’s team had stopped providing aid to the drought-hit Thar people.

He said the nation had reached a point of history where uncertainty was the rule and fear ruled every heart. “Terrorists want to take away our identities and existence,” he said, adding that people were asking for a way out from the blind alley. “What did we do that the history is not willing to forgive us?” he asked the audience.

Bilawal said Pakistan was facing multiple crises because the nation had buried a man 35 years ago who was like a beacon of light to the nation.“Zulfikar Ali Bhutto was a philosophy and an ideology; he was the man upon whom the poor relied,” he said, adding that his grandfather had transformed the country into a nuclear power.

Bilawal said he was worried while watching the Punjab being held hostage by terrorists. He said it wouldn’t have been the case if ZA Bhutto had been alive. “Pakistan needs a Bhutto once again today,” he remarked.

Lamenting the privatisation policy, Bilawal said the nation’s house was being auctioned without taking it into confidence. “If the government cannot run the country, does this mean we should sell it?” he asked.

Bilawal also criticised the PML-N government for abandoning the Pak-Iran Gas Pipeline Project. He questioned what price Pakistan had to pay for the money paid by a friendly country.He said the Pakistan Army was not the personal property of anyone. “Is the money given by a friendly country the price of heads of our Jawans? Our war is still underway and you are jumping into other countries’ wars,” he remarked.

He said unlike the silence of the Punjab government on the Joseph Colony incident, the PPP government in Sindh would not remain silent on demolition of temples.“Damaging and burning minorities’ worship places is not Islam,” he said, adding that he and his party workers would stand by the minorities if anybody tried to attack them. He urged the chief ministers of Balochistan, Sindh and KP to demand their respective provinces’ share of assets from the Centre.

Online adds: Speaking on the occasion, former president and Co-Chairman PPP Asif Ali Zardari on Friday recalled that the agreements signed by his government with China, the US and other countries and said the present rulers were now enjoying its benefits but the country was still facing the energy crisis .

Zardari paid tributes to ZA Bhutto and Benazir Bhutto for their sacrifices for the country and for never compromising with the military dictators.He also eulogised Bilawal for leading the caravan of Bhutto legacy. He raised the hands of a PPP candidate for PS-35 and asked the people of Larkana to vote for him and support him.

PPP parliamentarians and leaders including Syed Khursheed Shah, Raza Rabbani, Aitzaz Ahsan, Syed Qaim Ali Shah and others also addressed the event.The 35th death anniversary of ZA Bhutto was observed with reverence and respect. Thousands of party workers and leaders paid tributes to their legendary leader.