DUBAI: It
would be a little too early to say that battle lines have been drawn,
but serious polarisation has begun to show between forces, both
political and apolitical, on the issue of General Musharraf’s fate and
the once blurred lines are now getting clearer by the day.
After
meeting a number of well-informed people, both in khaki and civvies
over the last week in Islamabad, Karachi and Lahore, it was apparent
that the uncertainty below the surface is simmering, with everyone
waiting for the other to blink.
Supporters and opponents
of the political and security establishment are also coming out in the
open, judging the fast pace of the developments behind the scene. The
expected cooling down of the face-off led by the Defence Minister
Khawaja Asif has not yet happened and despite PM Sharif’s return from
China four days back, General Sharif has not called on him. Khawaja
Asif’s attempts to talk to the khakis have reportedly not produced any
result so far.
The pro-Musharraf elements have started
rallying and raising the temperature, day by day, degree by degree. The
MQM has been in the forefront to stir the pot. The Sindh Assembly scenes
of tearing up papers, shouting slogans as if it was the Bhaati Gate of
Lahore or Chowk Yadgar of Peshawar and the immediate calls for protests
in Karachi to be followed by the rest of Pakistan, are some of these
signs.
Although, Haider Abbas Rizvi of MQM, a serious
leader of the party, explained to me that the issue was of their missing
persons and extra-judicial killings, the timing seems more linked to
the tensions created by the Musharraf trial. The missing persons have
been missing for years and killings have been going on also for years,
both by security people and by rival political groups.
Likewise,
the PML-Q and Chaudhry Shujaat Hussain have come out in the open to
support Musharraf. Dr Tahirul Qadri has announced his plans to fill the
streets again in early May and Musharraf’s lawyers have been blatantly
taunting the military to save their ex-chief.
The
government camp has also rallied its supporters and the Nawaz-Zardari
meeting on Tuesday was a major attempt to demonstrate the strength of
the political side to the security establishment.
Statements
that came after the meeting focused on protecting and preserving
democracy, although no one has given any indication that the democratic
set-up was or could be under any threat. So basically it was a show of
muscle that politicians will again gang up if anyone had any overt or
covert ambitions.
Nevertheless, some high profile
political and non-political intermediaries have been working overtime
for a rapprochement so that things do not spin out of control. One of
these intermediaries, in a long talk, discussed the options the opposing
sides have if things do not quickly settle down for better.
First,
the military options; all concede that General Raheel Sharif has been
embarrassed before his boys as he had taken upon himself to solve the
matter. A military strategist and a political busybody told me identical
stories separately in two cities. The script for Musharraf’s exit had
been carefully written by trusted people, to the last dot. It was for
his safe flight on a special private jet that had arrived at Islamabad.
But hawks prevailed and the government side had second thoughts at the
fag end of the deal, after Musharraf and his side had honoured their
word — Musharraf had left the ICU, drove to the court, was indicted,
challenged his indictment and said a few political words and the court,
as expected, left it to the executive to let him go by removing his name
from the ECL. That is where the government side went off the designated
track.
The same night, almost in anger, Musharraf was
switched from the AFIC to his home in Chak Shahzad, without even the
knowledge of the civil authorities. He had been taken into protective
custody by his boys.
This deadlock was not taken lightly
by the Pindi boys. So what are General Raheel’s options, the informed
intermediary went on. “Three options are obvious. One that he tells his
commanders that he had failed and was quitting, so that someone else
should pick up the thread. Obviously, if he resigns, one of those under
him would have to be named as the new chief. A crisis would develop.
“The
second option was that the boys be asked to suggest what the chief
should do and Gen Raheel would then act accordingly. No one is ready to
predict what the collective decision could be but those who know the
boys don’t expect candies and cookies coming to Islamabad from Pindi.
“The
third possibility was that the standoff may be allowed to continue but
Musharraf could be whisked out in some manner that gives everyone a
face-saving solution. He could take off from Islamabad for Karachi and
then the plane develops ‘a fault’ or the weather ‘goes wrong’ or the
control tower of Karachi develops a ‘malfunction’ and his flight lands
in Dubai.”
Once he is out, the establishment then applies
some sort of a go-slow on a few fronts where the political government
needs them most. The talks with the Taliban get broken and when they
retaliate, the security around key places is somehow found to be slack
or something similar happens to bring the government under pressure.
The
report by our Lahore correspondent Amir Mir that a warning has already
been sent to the Afghan Taliban and the Haqqani Group to pick up one
side — TTP or the state of Pakistan — could mean strategists are already
working overtime to fix potential loopholes.
The message
would be: “Without taking over or disturbing the democratic set-up, the
military has enough aces up its sleeve.”The options for politicians are
tricky. If the government sticks to the hard line, does not reprimand
big talkers like Khawaja Asif and Saad Rafique and the Musharraf trial
gets underway on a fast track, as indicated by the special court,
matters could get much worse.
Politicians are grouping
together and will come closer if they feel the heat of a growing threat.
But if a new army chief has to be appointed, an Oct 12, 1999-like
situation may develop. Mian Nawaz Sharif and Asif Zardari must have
discussed these options in their one-on-one whispers. But both Sindh and
Punjab would be divided, the MQM going with Pindi as it needs badly
needed oxygen in London and Punjab politicians behaving like they always
do, go with the stronger party.
Balochistan and KP would
not matter much but Imran Khan has said repeatedly that he would not
support any out-of-the-constitutional box solution, yet Imran’s old and
time-tested top leadership has always been cozy with the Pindi boys,
barring a few oldies. So will Imran also face a split? May be, say
insiders.
The media would be a big player but already
splits are visible on the lines being seen in the political spectrum.
The West and the US would be confused at best and indifferent at worst
because they have their vested interests in coming weeks and months.
They would like a strong government in Islamabad that can deliver.
When
I had asked a top US diplomat in Islamabad last week whether he
favoured a “Track-2” between Pindi and Islamabad, his response was a big
laugh, with a crisp comment: “It is badly needed.” But he shrugged off a
suggestion to play any role.
The bottomline is that
someone, somewhere who can inject some sense, must intervene now and try
to get utopian, frivolous issues off the plate, as both the military
and the government have plenty of real issues to tackle.
“We
don’t need another five-year fight to restore democracy again, and for
whom, the politicians, who are themselves proving that the type of
democracy they are practising cannot handle the dirty fish in their
ranks, it cannot envisage real enemies and true friends and cannot time
its moves properly. It has to offer real solutions to real problems,”
said a Karachiite, known to be well-informed.