Showing posts with label Agencies. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Agencies. Show all posts

Tuesday, 10 June 2014

Agencies should focus on their job

ISLAMABAD: No cynicism involved, there is nothing personal though some may still doubt it, but let me request all our intelligence agencies; please, please, please focus on your job for the sake of Pakistan.

How many times would we still talk of failures, lapses and criminal negligence instead of learning lessons and improving our systems? For how long would we fight terrorism by sacrificing our soldiers, policemen, Rangers, officials of other law enforcing agencies and civilians?

Despite attacks after attacks by terrorists at their free will wherever they choose to, we haven’t learnt any lesson. The whole of Pakistan, including even the otherwise most secured strategically-important sites whether airports, air bases, military’s GHQ, air force and naval complexes, everything has appeared so far as easygoing for the terrorists.

Just half-a-dozen or even less number of terrorists, all in their teenage, can unnerve the whole of Pakistan. They have been repeatedly doing this in the recent years and did it again on Sunday night at the Karachi airport. They don’t enter the strategic places to capture such sites, rather want destruction, killing and most importantly create mayhem.

Getting them killed by the army, Rangers, police commandos etc. is normally a job of a few hours but by the time they are overpowered or killed, they would have achieved the objective of terrorising the whole country and making it a laughing stock in the whole world.

The challenge for Pakistan is not how many terrorists or militants are killed in a military/police offensive, the challenge is how could we preempt such terrorist attacks and how could we secure the life and property of the people as well as official installations and sites? Here comes the role of the intelligence agencies.

We have over two dozen agencies but none had a clue about half a dozen teenage terrorists — all foreigners as per the Karachi Rangers claim — who last night attacked the Karachi airport. They were carrying loads of sophisticated weapons, had supposedly travelled from Afghanistan to the tribal areas of Pakistan and then all the way to Karachi yet were not intercepted by any of the agency’s official.

They successfully entered the well-protected Karachi airport and easily achieved their target of terrorising Pakistan besides conveying to the whole world that it’s the most insecure place to live. Over a dozen law enforcers were martyred and this is how we fight terrorism here.

The over two dozen intelligence agencies of the country are said to have tens of thousands of agents. They have billions and billions of rupees at their disposal but still the teenage terrorists, their handlers and masterminds are beyond the agencies’ reach. Why is it so? What are these agencies doing? Is there anyone around who could hold these agencies accountable? What the agencies usually do is not a secret from the media, politicians, governments and even from the military establishment? The test is how to get the agencies focused on their prime job.

Tuesday, 22 April 2014

Pakistan has no law to govern intelligence agencies: Umar Cheema


 













ISLAMABAD: ‘The News’ investigative journalist Umer Cheema has said that no intelligence agency in Pakistan, including the ISI, MI and IB, had any law to govern their working.

Talking to Kamran Khan in ‘Aaj Kamran Khan Kay Sath’ show on Tuesday, Cheema said these intelligence agencies worked under the standard operating procedure due to which their work carried no legal value.

He said the Saleem Shahzad Commission report had also talked about intelligence reforms. He said even Bosnia had a law to govern the working of intelligence agencies.

He said a number of Central Asia states, which broke away from Russia, had suffered a lot at the hands of intelligence agencies and the first thing these states did after independence was that they introduced reforms for their intelligence agencies.

He said when Dr. Shoaib Suddle was DG Intelligence Bureau, he had made a law to govern the working of the agency but he was removed before he could present it to the government for presentation in Parliament.

He said the good omen for a county was that its rulers learn a lesson from their mistakes but unfortunately here in Pakistan we commit mistakes and repeat them. He said not even a single example existed in the United States where its premier intelligence agency CIA had ever kidnapped, attacked or killed a journalist.

Cheema mentioned the case of American computer professional and former employee of the CIA Edward Joseph Snowden. He said when Snowden was in the US he was not afraid of being abducted by the CIA and killed and dumped on the roadside rather he feared the US law.

He said one could imagine the consequences if someone in Pakistan had blown the whistle on the Inter-Services Intelligence or Military Intelligence (MI).Agreeing to Kamran Khan, Cheema said the CIA faced the allegation of killing President John F. Kennedy but there was not as much fuss and hue and cry from the intelligence agency against the accusation as was being witnessed in Pakistan these days.

He said a murder attempt had been made on senior journalist Hamid Mir and the channel pointed a finger at the ISI director general in the light of the attacked journalist’s statement that if something terrible happened to his life then the responsibility would lie with the agency. He said it was just an allegation but the security institutions were not ready to face it.

To a question, Cheema said that he was attacked in September 2010 after which he talked of ‘intelligence reforms’ and wrote many articles about it. “I did not talk of revenge and wanted to become part of the solution. Let’s find a solution to this problem. I also put blame on the ISI for beating me up. This should not happen to anyone,” Cheema said.

He further said, “Year 2014 has come. Mistakes can be made by anybody. Being a patriotic Pakistani, I think of the future of this country and am perturbed by it. We invest confidence over others but not in the Parliament. Whenever we see corruption, we expose it.”

To a question by Kamran Khan, Umer Cheema said that the ongoing talk on Geo was not of a single institution but of one personality. “We respect the ISI chief, but Hamid Mir is no lesser in status. He is a star anchor and has been attacked. He feels unsafe in his own country. He is afraid of those who are to save him, which for me as a Pakistani, is a shame,” he said, adding that a “Gentleman Agreement” was essential, and if not so, there should be legal limits for all.

To another question, Cheema said that the procedure for overall coverage should be changed. “Either we should not have aired the bakery-affair of Sharif family, or we should not have aired the picture of General Pasha with reference to Raymond Davis case? Moreover we should not have telecast the picture of DG IB when Benazir Bhutto was assassinated? Law should be equal for all,” he said.

Umar Cheema added that Hamid Mir had come to many people before this incident took place, and whatever he discussed was aired. He noted that the news with reference to ISI chief was aired and it is essential to present the picture of the person in question, which is a new phenomenon of electronic media. He further said that we were not mentally prepared for this new phenomenon in electronic media which had led to prejudice or obscurity. He said that when clarification came from DG ISPR, no one objected upon the airing of the picture of the DG. “Neither ISPR, nor ISI complained for telecasting his picture,” he clarified.

Responding to another query, journalist Umer Cheema said that back in 2010, his case was highlighted by the then opposition leader Chaudhry Nisar. “At that time Mian Nawaz Sharif also said that the ISI was involved in the case of Umer Cheema,” he said. Moreover, he said that at a certain stage, Chaudhry Nisar also demanded for the resignation of General Pasha, which led Cheema to question if law was not applicable in this case.

In response to a query, Cheema said that Chaudhry Nisar should clarify whether he was wrong then or right.In reply to a question, Umer Cheema said that the government’s spokesman Pervaiz Rashid had said many things between the lines. He said that those groups, who talked with arguments, were standing together with the government and civil society. He said that this statement was different from that of Chaudhry Nisar. “Perhaps the office of Chaudhry Sahib has some requirements, or he is playing the role of a fire fighter which he wants to retain,” Cheema said.

To a query, Cheema said that we knew only to rule over the ignorant. “We talk of only those things which the people want to listen to. If we turned to a different talk, they will call you a ‘traitor’. There is a dearth of media’s overall training. We should also enforce relevant code of conduct,” he added.

Umar Cheema, responding to a question, said that his opinion was not necessarily the prefect one. He added that everyone had his own opinion about a thing or two. He noted that if it could be highlighted that someone was being blamed then also Hamid Mir was not an ordinary man; he held a respectable status in journalism, and if his family said that they had his recorded statement, this was a newsworthy thing. However, he said that some people might not conform to this opinion, but he opined that a meeting should be held to decide whether or not this opinion be revisited, as there is always a room for improvement.

Speaking on the show, Editor Investigations ‘The News’ Ansar Abbasi, to a question Kamran Khan about his demand that the ISI chief should step down after the attack on Hamid Mir, said he had said that it was a serious allegation raised by Hamid Mir and his brother Amir Mir pointing a finger at the DG ISI. He said this allegation caused bashing of the institution and he thought that institution should be protected as individuals do not matter.

He said if he were in place of the DG ISI, he would have stepped down so that allegation is not made on the ISI and the institution is not bashed worldwide. He said many people including Mir’s brother shared his opinion.

Asked why he did not advocate going to court to prove the allegations, Abbasi said this matter is not about allegations and indictment. He said he is talking about respect of the institution as the whole world is bashing the ISI now. He said if the allegations are proved, it will be a matter of shame for the country. He said he wants to protect the ISI from bashing.

Kamran Khan pointed out that allegations were also levelled against Nawaz Shaif and Iftikhar Chaudhry but none of them left the office.Abbasi said what he had said was his opinion and not that of Geo TV. He said if his opinion is in violation of the Constitution, it should be taken to the court of law.

Kamran Khan again pointed to Arslan Iftikhar case and the fact that they did not at that time demanded that Iftikhar Chaudhry should leave office.Abbasi said Malik Riaz had told him that he had evidence against Arslan but he did not have any evidence against the then chief justice. He questioned if a son did something wrong, should the father be punished?

He said Hamid Mir is not an ordinary person. He said Hamid Mir had shared these allegations with many persons, so what should we do now? He said wrongly or rightly, Mir had shared his apprehensions with top management of Geo TV.

He said things should not be twisted. He repeated that DG ISI is not more important as an individual than the institution. He said he thinks that if you remove the DG, you save the institution of the ISI. He said it is his viewpoint which can be rejected.

He explained that this is not the opinion of his organisation. He said he often speaks against his organisation so when he is doing so, how can it be opinion of his organisation.

Kamran Khan questioned how things will be settled when the Defence Ministry has accessed the Pemra against Geo TV, and the Interior Ministry also disliked the coverage.

Ansar Abbasi said there should be a fair deal as he is a man of rule of law. He said he only called for a fair deal but his comments were stretched beyond limits. He said, “Leave me. I am a traitor. Every body in Jang Group is a ‘traitor’. We all should be given medals for being traitor.”

He said those levelling allegations against them should monitor their activities. He said totally free media is a dangerous thing. He said had Pemra been doing right things, it should have called Geo TV to restrict if any red line was being crossed. He said Pemra has asked the media to show restrain at the time of Chehlum tragedy in Rawalpindi because there was a risk of violence in the country.

He said why Pemra and the government were sleeping at the time of transmission of Hamid Mir attack. He questioned why Pemra did not make a phone call to mention that Hamid Mir’s allegations are wrong and these pictures should not be aired on the media. He said he has objections to the working of Pemra which took no notice of abuse of the former chief justice, adding that the government and the Pemra should regulate themselves.

Kamran Khan questioned how should they defend themselves at a time when the ministries of interior and defence are levelling serious allegations against them?

Ansar Abbasi said Pemra is the body to deal with media legally and the ministers criticising the media are not in apposition to do so. He said Pemra should hear the ministries. He said justice should done with them (media) and the Ministry of Defence. He said if an assurance for such a justice is made, then they should fully submit to the law. He said they could go to the independent judiciary in case of any injustice.

Abbasi said there should be no conflict between military and civil government portraying his or others’ statements on Geo TV. He said some channels are stocking fire. He said he heard at a channel that the prime minister is siding with Geo TV but the interior minister and some other people are on the other side.

Ansar Abbasi has said that a divide is being created because of them but for them, national interest is supreme. He said they would never want that a dark environment is created because of them in the country. He said they should submit to the law as they believe in institutions. He said those who oppose should put up all their complaints to Pemra. He added fire is being stocked by wrong interpretations of their statements and these issues should be brought before the institutions concerned

Saturday, 5 April 2014

No respite in phone tapping by agencies



 












ISLAMABAD: While there has been an overall failure in countering terrorism, instances of unnecessary and unethical recording of common citizens and government officials’ telephone calls have multiplied.
Prime Minister Nawaz Sharif’s decision to grant an extension to the chief of a big intelligence agency is also against his own publicly-made pledges. The government has started a controversial process of bestowing extensions which was the benchmark of the Musharraf and Zardari regimes.

The prime minister’s decision to grant extension is a violation of the Supreme Court’s clear judgment not to give extensions unnecessarily, especially on cadre posts where other eligible officers are present. The PML-N had condemned previous regimes on this count on many occasions. Officials believe that accepting the extension is the first major negative point of a spotless career of the chief of the big intelligence agency, who otherwise enjoys a reputation of being an honest and competent officer.

Under the principles of good governance, impartiality and justice, no officer is indispensable for the system, and new officers are always trusted and given opportunities to serve. This is considered the hallmark of a system which is trying to get rid of the status quo. Extensions are mostly granted in the name of honesty and competence, but experts believe that a strong system always prepares and trains officers, gives them top assignments and, consequently, this practice becomes instrumental in the transformation of a corrupt system into a comparatively better system.

When the head of the big agency was asked the same questions by The News he said, “I have stood by the same principle throughout my career and always preached the same.” He said that during his last meeting with the head of the government on the eve of his retirement, the prime minister asked him: “You have worked 37 years for yourselves and now your country needs your services.” He said that he was speechless and was unable to counter this argument. “I was also fearing that the next sentence from the chief executive of the federation could be that I have no time for Pakistan,” he said adding, “I can never hear this sentence.”

The civilian as well as army-controlled intelligence outfits had completely failed to apprehend any single major terrorism activity in the recent past. Even the district courts of the federal capital were attacked in a bizarre fashion by the terrorists a few weeks back and so far there is no clue to any terrorist group involved in the heinous and terrible act.

However, there have been a large number of instances where the illegal recording of calls have been reported and this practice is on the rise as days pass. The intelligence agencies not only tap calls but also use the transcripts to achieve certain objectives, including pressuring individuals. Intelligence agencies also remain unable to control some of the cellular operators from indulging in the same illegal activity only because they themselves do the same instead of pursuing terrorists and anti-state actors.

However, senior government officials say that the present government is not interested in using the intelligence agencies for tapping calls. These top government officials argue by quoting some instances to make their point. Officials say that the political party ruling the federation mostly makes the government in Quetta, and the intelligence agencies are extensively used to achieve this objective. However, the present ruling party opted to give the government of Balochistan to another party. Similarly, the political party ruling Islamabad also successfully makes the government in AJK with the help of the agencies, but Prime Minister Nawaz Sharif has stopped a move in the past to empower the PML-N in Muzaffarabad.

These top officials also argue that the agencies can remove the provincial government in Peshawar in a few days but it has never been on the agenda of the present federal government.

All these points are fine. However, it is a fact that instances of recording common citizens’ calls are increasing and there is no check in this regard. This has badly affected the performance of the intelligence agencies and officials at the helm of affairs in these institutions are unable to defined the priorities for such practices.

Monday, 10 March 2014

Agencies gathering details of NGOs, visit Kishwar Naheed

Minister for Defence Khawaja Muhammad Asif is to be briefed by members of local and international Non Governmental Organisations (NGOs), about government agencies using the name of the Ministry of Defence while carrying out their investigations.

On Monday, the country’s leading poet Ms Kishwar Naheed who runs an NGO, Hawwa Women Craft Cooperatives, was approached by an official who said she was from the Ministry of Defence and wanted Ms Naheed to fill a form giving details about Hawwa. “She was a young well groomed lady, who said she was here from the Ministry of Defence and wanted me to fill a form giving details about Hawwa. When I demanded to see some sort of identification, she showed me her identification papers which clearly showed that she was working for the Inter Services Intelligence (ISI). When I asked her why she was lying, she said I must speak to someone, who she got on her phone,” Ms Naheed told The News.

A ‘major sahib’ came on the line and requested Ms Naheed to fill the form.“I have years of working experience and demanded that there should be a letter of authority requesting that a certain form should be filled and why. If it is an authoritative letter, I will not hesitate to fill it, as I have nothing to hide.

I told the ISI official that she should leave the form and I will have a look at it,” added Ms Naheed.Soon the lady from the ISI talked to the ‘major sahib’ once again, and later asked Ms Naheed to return the form and then left.

Later a representative of an international NGO told The News: “The ISI has certainly changed its manner of functioning and has now recruited young and pleasant-mannered ladies. It appears the era of the major sahib and colonel sahib walking into offices and homes has changed. But this ISI official was a complete novice. No spook ever reveals which agency he or she is working for, rarely shows identification papers and normally spooks name another agencies for cover.”

The News had recently reported that the government was in the process of bringing in a fresh law for all NGO’s working in Pakistan. The ISI questioner had questions related to the workings of NGO’s but it is not clear as to why before the new law has come into effect this exercise is being taken up.

“The ISI is a national institution and if it has some genuine questions about Hawwa, I do not have any problems. But this visit by the ISI has left me very uncomfortable,” says Ms Naheed.Representatives of local and international NGO’s when they heard about the experience of Ms Naheed feel they should meet the minister of defence to get some clarity about these new forms for NGO’s and whether the Ministry had been taken into confidence by ISI about this new procedure.Telephone calls made to the ISPR and Ministry of Defence and text messages to get their side of the story remained unanswered.